Monday, July 14, 2014

A Future for Philosophy of Technology - Yes, But On Which Planet?



[This is a talk I gave at the Society for Philosophy and Technology, Lisbon, July 2013.  It has now been published in a Chinese Journal, Engineering Studies, but here's the English version.]

A Future for Philosophy of Technology -- Yes, But On Which Planet?

By:  Langdon Winner
        Thomas Phelan Chair of Humanities and Social Sciences
        Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, New York

It is gratifying to see a once rather obscure topic of inquiry – philosophy of technology – become the diverse and vibrant field of study it is today.  Especially notable are several blends of social science, history and philosophy that scholars are cultivating at present.  Since I am not eager to suggest new pathways for those already at work on these interesting projects, I will simply point to a couple avenues that seem especially interesting and urgent to me.

1. Democracy and security

Within the domain of information technology and its relationship to the future of political society there are a many theoretical and practical questions that are wide open for study and speculation.  During the past several decades a steady flow predictions and practical programs have sought to clarify about the horizons of networked computing, some of them pointing to a new era of democratic participation.   

A common argument holds that inexpensive computing and communication in a variety of novel forms empowers everyday people, enhancing their capacity for self-government.  Over the years I have remained skeptical about claims of this kind.  Since the early 19th century there has been long litany of proclamations in the grand tradition of techno-utopianism about the politically redemptive power of the steam engine, railroads, telegraph, centrally generated electrical power, the automobile, radio, television, and other technologies.  Ideas in this vein often feature an underlying belief in a benevolent technological determinism accompanied by an unwillingness to raise questions about the steps needed to prevent the rise of obnoxious concentrations of economic and political power. 

In recent years, however, I have been encouraged by evidence of depth and substance in writings about the information and networks that suggest a strong possibility that ordinary citizens could actually be empowered by information networks.  Philosophical discussions of the Internet and of social networks now sometime include imaginative, coherent, well-argued, well-documented, and highly persuasive positions about the actual promise that information technologies hold out for community, public participation, democracy and social justice now and in the future.  Some notable advocates for these hopes have clearly moved beyond barefoot technological determinism and dreamy utopianism to specify concretely what the possibilities are and how they might be fully realized.  

A good example is the work of Yochai Benkler.  In  The Wealth of Networks and his more recent book, The Penguin and the Leviathan, Benkler observes that during the past 30 years or so the basic capital requirements of an information economy have shifted.  “The declining price of computation, communication, and storage have …placed the material means of information and cultural production in the hands of a significant fraction of the world’s population.”  Rapidly falling costs of technology support the rise of a “networked information economy” increasingly characterized by “cooperative and coordinate action carried out through radically distributed, nonmarket mechanisms that do not depend on proprietary strategies.”[1]  Benkler builds upon this basic argument to explore a variety of ways in which everyday people are using today’s information networks to rediscover the power of a cooperative economy and to fashion ways to revitalize participative democracy. 

In short, the recent contributions of Yochai Benkler, Lawrence Lessig, Robert McChesney and other thinkers offer detailed, forward looking arguments about possibilities the Net contains along with stern advice about what would involved in struggles to draw upon information technologies to create a more democratic future.   Aware of patterns that might proliferate in a networked society -- centralized, hierarchical, power oriented, ultimately oppressive, corporate structures – writings that defend a more open, more inclusive future have begun to offer alternatives to the well worn intellectual furniture used to buttress the old industrial model.   One such contribution is the deconstruction and reconsideration of the threadbare but still high venerated fictions known as “property” and “property rights,” recently resurfaced as “intellectual property” for faster transit on the information throughways of globalization.  A fruitful alternative, the new writings suggest, is to explore notions and practices of “the commons” in a world that now combines pervasive electronic connections with familiar cultural, economic and political institutions as well as humanity’s complex relationships to nature.  What is the status of things that should rightfully be shared in common?  Why must neoliberal obsessions with “property” and the imaginary of “free markets” dominate policy discussions when there are now robust alternatives?

At the same time, and in stark contrast to work on these hopeful, speculative themes, there have arisen new concerns about ominous patterns of corporate power now commanded by information giants – Google, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, an others – especially the political character of their relationships to their everyday users.   The configuration of power and authority that characterizes these organizations now is very far from distributed democracy in which ordinary people are the beneficiaries of computer power.  Some Silicon Valley experts who study the new regimes of computer system security argue that the actual, emerging relationship in the era of “cloud computing” amounts to kind of feudalism in which powerless individuals seek shelter in a world of large information corporations that function as lords of the realm.   Ordinary, every computer users have no real power over firms that manage the data about them, but must somehow find ways to trust these companies to behave responsibly.[2]   Of course, the amount of data the large Internet firms have over one’s life and communications, the capacities for surveillance they command, suggests that such trust may not be justified at all    In effect, everyday computer users are reduced to the condition of techno-serfs, powerless participants in the Net who find themselves fully subservient to the new lords of the realm.

The situation is especially egregious in light on the military-security-industrial complex that has expanded so quickly during the years following the terrorist attacks in the U.S.A. of September 11, 2001.   In the spring of 2013 a wave of the stunning reports by Edward Snowden, former employee of the National Security Agency and its corporate contractors, revealed the extensive power of surveillance over US. citizens and elected leaders in the U.S., Europe and elsewhere around the world.  Backdoor channels that Google and other Internet giants have crafted with the N.S.A. make the phone calls, web browsing, email, and other Internet centered activities of everyone (not just suspected terrorists) visible to government authorities with little if any limitation or legal oversight.   Laws that supposedly protect the rights and liberties of citizens are regularly and secretly breached when it suits the purposes of a matrix that now blends government and corporate power. 

Although the relevant questions for philosophers are many and complicated, the basic question comes down to this.   Will the future be characterized by the open informational society imagined by today’s internet visionaries, or the closed, menacing information/security state that fills our newspaper headlines.  What kinds of political order are likely to emerge or ought to be crafted in ever advancing systems of information technology?  What kinds of limits should be strongly installed against insidious threats to our freedom?

The measures that legal scholar Alan Westin urged for privacy protection and recognition of citizen rights at the dawn of “the information society” decades ago were seldom if ever realized in practice.  Alas, his argument that people must insist upon a right to control the information gathered about their lives and activities is an insight that now seems a mere historical relic.

In this light, my suggestion would be that philosophers vigorously renew their speculation and argumentation about the political character of the networked society and the qualities of public life it contains.  Edward Snowden’s reasons for leaking what he’d learned about N.S.A. and corporate information systems are simple yet heart rending.  I don’t want to live in a world where everything that I say, everything I do, everyone I talk to, every expression of creativity or love or friendship is recorded. And that’s not something I’m willing to support, it’s not something I’m willing to build, and it’s not something I’m willing to live under. So I think anyone who opposes that sort of world has an obligation to act in the way they can.”[3]  

2.  Unthinkable changes

As I looked over the program for the Summer 2013 meeting of the Society for Philosophy and Technology I noted with great pleasure the range, diversity and quality of the topics the various scholars would be discussing.   But as I read the titles of papers as well as of some of the abstracts and essays, a gnawing question began to arise:  Upon what planet do today’s philosophers of technology think they  are living?  And in what period of human history do they imagine themselves to be involved? 

Trajectories of development within prominent schools of thought and in policy deliberations seemed familiar and yet strangely oblivious to some obvious emergencies that have powerfully surfaced in our time and that will surely disrupt the agendas of philosophical and social inquiry in the decades of the 21st century.  Much of philosophical thinking still quietly presupposes and leaves unquestioned basic underlying conditions of that have served as foundations for the rise and continuation of modern industrial societies.  

There now at least two general conditions that philosophers, STS scholars and world societies at large can no longer take for granted, ones that challenge us to ponder the distinct possibility that the advanced technological societies in which we live may soon be forced into paroxysms of drastic change.  One vastly important situation is our long-standing dependence upon the cheap, readily available petroleum that fuels virtually every function of our technological civilization.  Taking my own society as an example, America’s factories, homes, cities, automobiles, trucks, airplanes, and the rest all presuppose the primary condition of their creation, namely a steady supply of oil at roughly $20 a barrel.   That price threshold vanished many years ago, replaced a $100 or more price tag, a point at which the whole interconnected system begins to stall out.  No one likes to talk about it, but since the financial crash of 2008 the U.S.A has been essentially a no growth society.  While there are many reasons for this predicament, the price of petroleum is certainly a key determinant.  There is not much building going on in America, while profuse evidence of deterioration in crucial material and social systems, the nation’s infrastructure for example, is everywhere to be seen.

In my reading of the steady stream of reports on energy, economy and society, the peak in extraction of conventional fossil fuels has already been passed.  While there is now a modest boom in “unconventional” fossil fuels – tar sands, “tight oil” and natural gas from hydraulic fracturation (“fracking”) – the economic and environmental costs of such alternatives are daunting and their long term prospects highly uncertain at best.  Equally important, there are no cheap, easily installed replacements for the petroleum energy resources that have served as the foundation for industrial societies during the past century.  What we see today is a frantic stampede to grab what’s left of fossil fuel resources through deep sea drilling, “fracking” and dead end technologies.  This means that our grossly overpowered civilization faces a period in which it will be forced to power down rather soon and with astonishing rapidity.[4]

It is possible that this transition could offer highly favorable possibilities for human wellbeing – new ways of living more lightly on the earth, new forms of community and human relationships superior ones that have characterized the materialistic consumer society of recent decades.   Will philosophers have a role in exploring those possibilities?  For the time being it appears that although they are not in complete denial about the implications of the end of cheap fossil fuels, the basic perspective of most philosophers of technology remains that of business as usual, the expectation that our way of life will continue to chug along basically unchanged from patterns of the past two century.   

Along with a frank recognition of the many-sided energy crisis ahead, a second, closely related condition demands our attention.  The most fundamental functioning of modern technological societies depends upon the existence of a stable, favorable climate.  As most scholars surely recognize by this time, conditions of climatological stability that have favored the rise of world civilizations for the past 10,000 years or so are now undergoing rapid change caused by the warming of the Earth as a consequence of carbon gases released by human activity.   While estimates vary, the scientific consensus among a wide range of disciplines now points to global warming of 2 to 4 degrees Celsius or more by the end of this century, temperatures that bring monster storms, wicked droughts, floods, melting ice caps, rising seas, and other calamities often lumped together under the comforting term “climate change,” but better identified by English writer George Mombiot’s label, “climate crash.”

The science that supports such findings is truly impressive.  A decade ago, researchers predicted that melting ice in the arctic would shift weather patterns northward on the North American continent.  This would bring far less rain in the western states of the U.S.A. with persistent droughts and burning wild fires throughout the region.   Today that has become the new normal.

During the past two decades both the weight of evidence and intensity of warnings from climate scientists has increased.  As the research group Real Climate announced in 2009: “We feel compelled to note that even a “moderate” warming of 2°C stands a strong chance of provoking drought and storm responses that could challenge civilized society, leading potentially to the conflict and suffering that go with failed states and mass migrations. Global warming of 2°C would leave the Earth warmer than it has been in millions of years, a disruption of climate conditions that have been stable for longer than the history of human agriculture.[5] 

In short, both the impending energy crisis and climate crash will, with a high degree of certainty, produce a lengthy period of disruption within humanity’s most fundamental material, social, cultural, and political patterns.  Many of the institutions, practices, relationships, and beliefs that philosophers and social scientists are busily studying and reporting in their conferences and journals will be placed under severe stress (or worse). 

To dramatize their theories and speculations, philosophers sometimes talk about “ruptures” in historical thinking that their inquiries seek to describe.  Well, if you have a taste for rupture, there are a great number of them on the near horizon.  They present us with a wide range of challenging questions of which I can only mention a few. 

What kind of world will be or should be created in response to the extraordinary conditions humanity will confront?

What kinds of people and relationships will this world contain?

What will its basic institutions and technologies be?   What will become of the ideology of limitless expansion and techno-triumphalism that has characterized the longings of our political and economic elites in recent decades?

During the decades ahead philosophies of technology must somehow come to terms with extreme, ultimately physical ruptures for which we are now utterly unprepared.  Once again, as Cold War intellectuals advised, we must begin “thinking about the unthinkable.”  Unlike the situation presented by the specter of the atomic bomb, however, the world changing forces we must think about today are not possibilities buried in covert weapons silos, but realities already fully apparent to anyone who cares to notice.






References

[1]   Yochai Benkler, The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2006) p. 3.

[2]  Bruce Schneier, “You Have No Control Over Security on the Feudal Internet,” Harvard Business Review, June 6, 2013 [https://www.schneier.com/essay-430.html]

[3]   Edward Snowden, full transcript of interview conducted by Glenn Greenwald and Laura Poitras, in the website “Mondoweis”  [http://mondoweiss.net/2013/07/i-dont-want-to-live-in-a-world-where-every-expression-of-creativity-or-love-or-friendship-is-recorded-full-transcript-of-snowdens-latest-interview.html]

[4]    A good survey of the situation in energy can be found in the work of Richard Heinberg, especially his books The End of Growth: Adapting to Our New Economic Reality (Gabriola Island, BC Canada, 2011) and Snake Oil: How Fracking’s False Promise of Plenty Imperils Our Future (Santa Rosa, CA: Post Carbon Institute, 2013).

[5]  “Hit the brakes Hard,” editorial in the website “Real Climate: Climate science from climate scientists,” April 29, 2009  [http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/04/hit-the-brakes-hard/

76 comments:

  1. Phenq Reviews and testimonials of this popular diet pill, PhenQ Scam? ... We are going to introduce you a PhenQ. .... Most Popular Saving Offer April 2016

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous1:55 PM

    Are you need gutter cleaning tampa Services | 100% Guaranteed | Get your free instant quote today | Providing Affordable Gutter Cleaning in Tampa,Know more please go our sete and get more about my service…

    ReplyDelete
  3. I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The biosphere gasification technology or simply called biosphere technology is a kind of green technology that the biosphere machine uses to be able produce electricity. Biosphere technology is a process of turning waste to green energy in a cost effective manner. Biosphere technology is different from the other this website that diminish waste. I came across also with a kind of green technology invented by the Japanese that transform waste to environmental by-products.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The field of education is constantly changing and growing with technology. In this digital era, children grow up with computers from the time they are very young. In order to reach these children, educators need to adapt to compliance in education and learn how to teach students using technological tools.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You are about to learn about a review tip offered to a local business CEO about who was assassinating their reputation and possibly causing the business to lose profits right from the businesses bottom line, which could possibly be happening in your business? I was going to wait for the CEO to reply after my initial contact but I knew this person was busy so I wanted to give the https://cad.cheapsoftwaredownload.net/ all the facts up front to make any decisions on in this matter that had to be made.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 14 Strategies We Attribute to Our Recent Business Excellence Award - Out of the blue, I received an email from the Abbotsford Chamber of Commerce one day notifying me that we were nominated for a 2016 Business Excellence award. Say what? Once I got past my shock and disbelief that they must have the wrong Susan. coreldraw 2018 buy online

    ReplyDelete
  8. This article provides an overview of the used truck trailer market. These trailers, also known as semi-trailers, include dry freight van (box) trailers, flatbed (platform) trailers, drop deck (step deck) trailers, and refrigerated van trailers. Truck trailers haul a majority of products that are manufactured and shipped in the United States. canvas cover trailers

    ReplyDelete
  9. Bitzarena.comis the site that provides latest and updated news about the world, technology,business, mobile, etc. It also provides latest information about thetechnological world.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Blog commenting or writing is a great way to interact and relate to various individuals in and out of your community. Nonetheless, it's still very important to observe some guidelines and exercise a little discretion when commenting or writing Blogs. Try to keep them short and moderate and try to be as honest as you possibly can. Improve website

    ReplyDelete
  11. Even hunters need to have a magazine dedicated to their needs, just like everyone else. The Bow Arrow Hunting magazine comes forward just to fulfill that need. It is an all-purpose and all-round magazine, as you will discover for yourself as you read further! waders for hunting

    ReplyDelete
  12. Newer, faster, shinier - these are all things that every product manager wants their product to be. Our hearts are filled with product lust when we see other products, in our space or not, that have the latest & greatest bells and whistles. Oh if only our product could have that cool new technology also. Hang on a minute, it turns out that our products might actually be more successful if they don't have that cool new technology... youtube vanced

    ReplyDelete
  13. A reverse mortgage calculator is a tool used to estimate the amount of money an individual might be able to receive through a reverse mortgage. To use a reverse mortgage calculator, seniors simply input their age, home value, existing mortgage balance and estimated interest rate. The calculator will use this information to determine whether the individual could qualify for a reverse mortgage, as well as how much the person stands to receive. hours calculator add

    ReplyDelete
  14. Without a written plan of action for many of our lives, there was be disorder and chaos. This can be especially true with technology in our homes. In this article, I discuss 7 Benefits of Creating a Household Technology Plan. Durometer

    ReplyDelete
  15. กำจัดปลวกเชียงใหม่ ( chiangmai termite ) เป็นบริษัทกำจัดปลวกเชียงใหม่ ฉีดปลวกเชียงใหม่ราคาถูก เน้นความคุ้มค่า เพื่อลดค่าใช้จ่ายของลูกค้า. มีขั้นตอนการฉีดปลวกเหมือนกับบริษัทใหญ่ราคาแพง. ฉีดปลวกเชียงใหม่

    ReplyDelete
  16. Web hosting is surely a developing industry. Web hosts are mushrooming in a similar way that a significant enormous number of new websites are added every day to the billions of sites on the web. Why do individuals join with a web hosting organization? the best web hosting companies

    ReplyDelete
  17. A web host's job may seem pretty simple, but there are numerous tasks which go on daily at their workplace. This article lists the customer facing tasks which a web host needs to carry out on a daily basis. This article goes behind the scenes in presenting what a web hosting company does on a daily basis, from a front office point of view. wokehosting

    ReplyDelete


  18. It's true that humans are not the only one who will be benefiting from this but also other living things in the entire click here to view more...

    ReplyDelete
  19. Drupal web development is all about providing exclusive and unmatchable features and functionalities. With Drupal as a content management system, you can customize your business website with some amazing features like modifying the layouts, allowing users to register on personal accounts, rich graphic user interface, RSS feeds and innovatively displaying the menus of the website. Depression Clinic South Melbourne

    ReplyDelete
  20. Small businesses need to be in tune with the proper, updated technology. If they are using old, outdated technology or broken systems, then you are doing more harm than good and your business will suffer as a result. how to spy camera

    ReplyDelete
  21. The development of Wireless technology owes it all to Michael Faraday - for discovering the principle of electromagnetic induction, to James Maxwell - for the Maxwell's equations and to Guglielmo Marconi - for transmitting a wireless signal over one and a half miles. The sole purpose of Wireless technology is wireless communication, through which information can be transferred between two or more points that are not connected by electrical conductors. Wireless technologies were in use since the advent of radios, which use electromagnetic transmissions. Eventually, consumer electronics manufacturers started thinking about the possibilities of automating domestic micro-controller based devices. Timely and reliable relay of sensor data and controller commands were soon achieved, which led to the discovery of Wireless communications that we see everywhere now. route planner

    ReplyDelete
  22. How important is quality control in construction? How is this done? empresas reformas zaragoza

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Construction has really emerged strongly once again. Fresh investment is flowing in and both the private firms and government organizations are spending generously in infrastructural developments all across the globe. reformas de pisos en zaragoza

    ReplyDelete
  25. How important is quality control in construction? How is this done? empresas reformas zaragoza

    ReplyDelete
  26. AOT Compressor is One of leading compressors manufacturer in the world, Check lpg compressor price and offers Ipg compressor oil Families Solutions, LPG compressor durable,low consumption and longer life.we offers for all your lpg compressor ,cng compressor,oxygen compressor,hydrogen compressor Parts shortages needs. that you can save your money and time and also have nothing to worry. lpg compressor

    ReplyDelete
  27. If there is any word that defines the fast paced world we live in today, its "technology". With the passage of time, technology has become an immensely powerful and rapidly growing arena. As such it is important to grow along with it, to be updated with the latest trends. best Surveillance system

    ReplyDelete
  28. The use of technology is becoming pervasive, both in the home and in the workplace. Because of this, technological expectations within the educational setting are increasing. Many of the students we see are being raised without knowing what it is like to be without computer access. Factors such as the wealth of information on the "Web" as well as presentation software products like PowerPoint are all transforming the educational system. Teachers are gaining proficiency in computer skills and demands by students and parents have made these new skills imperative. Planning for the needed training, the monetary investment, and for the specific methods of integrating technology into the established educational system is necessary to make the most of those technologies. access control system

    ReplyDelete
  29. The word "Technology" is soon to vanish. Its place shall be occupied by "Green Technology". Green technology may be costlier to implement as all R&D projects are but in the long run it shall be cheaper in all respect. Cutting down on costlier raw material consumption and recycling zero cost waste as raw material will certainly make green products cost friendly and help to carve a better world to live. We are on a faster track so is the march of green technology. Lillian

    ReplyDelete
  30. For anyone with a passion for technology, this degree is a serious pathway to success. An MBA (Technology Management) is an online MBA degree that one can do from the convenience of home. So what does this course entail? Teletalk offer 2021

    ReplyDelete
  31. Packaging equipment can benefit businesses both big and small. Though speed is a major asset for machinery, there do exist a number of other benefits as well. auto repair

    ReplyDelete
  32. For anyone with a passion for technology, this degree is a serious pathway to success. An MBA (Technology Management) is an online MBA degree that one can do from the convenience of home. So what does this course entail? thoptv apk

    ReplyDelete
  33. Throughout my years of movie watching and electronics sales, I have noticed one trend that I find kind of amusing, and might help explain how we *cough* "know" who the Nerds are... Technology. Say what you will about Nerds, nerds and technology are almost interchangeable terms. Regardless of whatever else they are fans of, nerds LOVE their technology, and are often the first to embrace the newest technological advances. best xmind alternative

    ReplyDelete
  34. Despite bad economy situation, cars are playing a major part in our everyday life and it is absolutely required cost for every household Auto verkaufen Oberhausen

    ReplyDelete
  35. Selamat siang untuk seluruh WNI dan juga seluruh ASIA, nama saya Bu Nurliana Novi, mohon, saya ingin membagikan testimoni hidup saya di sini pada platform ini untuk semua WNI dan seluruh asia agar berhati-hati dengan pemberi pinjaman di internet, Allah benar-benar telah mendukung saya melalui ibu. Ibu Elina yang baik hati

    Setelah beberapa periode mencoba mendapatkan pinjaman dari lembaga keuangan, dan ditolak terus-menerus, jadi saya memutuskan untuk mendaftar melalui pinjaman online tetapi saya ditipu dan saya kehilangan Rp 15.000.000 dengan pemberi pinjaman yang berbeda.

    Saking nekadnya mendapatkan pinjaman, maka saya berdiskusi dengan teman saya yang kemudian mengenalkan saya kepada Bu Elina yang merupakan pemilik perusahaan pemberi pinjaman global, maka teman saya tersebut meminta saya untuk melamar ke Bu Elina, maka saya pun memberanikan diri. dan menghubungi Nyonya Elina.

    Saya mengajukan pinjaman sejumlah Rp500.000.000 dengan tingkat bunga 2%, sehingga pinjaman disetujui dengan mudah tanpa stres dan semua pengaturan dilakukan pada transfer kredit, karena tidak memerlukan agunan dan jaminan untuk pinjaman transfer Saya hanya diberitahu untuk mendapatkan sertifikat perjanjian lisensi aplikasi Mereka untuk mentransfer kredit saya dan dalam waktu kurang dari dua jam uang pinjaman telah disimpan ke rekening bank saya.

    Saya pikir itu lelucon sampai saya menerima telepon dari bank saya bahwa rekening saya dikreditkan dengan jumlah Rp500.000.000. Saya sangat senang bahwa ALLAH akhirnya menjawab doa saya dengan memesan pinjaman saya dengan pinjaman asli saya, yang telah memberikan saya keinginan hati saya.

    Mereka juga memiliki tim ahli yang akan memberi tahu Anda tentang jenis bisnis yang ingin Anda investasikan dan bagaimana menginvestasikan uang Anda, sehingga Anda tidak akan pernah bangkrut lagi dalam hidup Anda.

    Semoga ALLAH memberkati Bunda Elina yang telah membuat hidup saya mudah, jadi saya menyarankan siapapun yang berminat untuk mendapatkan pinjaman agar dapat menghubungi Ibu Elina melalui email: elinajohnson22@gmail.com untuk pinjaman anda
    Ada perusahaan palsu online lainnya yang menggunakan kesaksian saya untuk mencapai keinginan egois mereka, saya satu-satunya dengan kesaksian yang benar ini, ketika Anda menghubungi kemudian meminta mereka untuk bukti pembayaran ke ibu`` tolong hati-hati orang-orang ini oke

    Akhir kata saya ucapkan terima kasih kepada kalian semua yang telah meluangkan waktu untuk membaca kesaksian hidup saya yang sebenarnya tentang kesuksesan saya dan saya berdoa semoga Tuhan melakukan kehendak-Nya dalam hidup kalian. Satu lagi nama saya mrs nurliana novi, kalian dapat menghubungi saya untuk informasi lebih lanjut. melalui email saya: nurliananovi96@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  36. Computer PC software is so called in contrast to computer hardware, which encompasses the physical interconnections and devices required to store and execute (or run) the software. Software is an ordered sequence of instructions for changing the state of the computer hardware in a... smm panel

    ReplyDelete
  37. Want to go faster? Here are the top 5 motocross mods to ensure that your bike will be able to handle it. In order to go faster, your bike must be set-up correctly to handle it. Carbon Road Bicycle Wheels

    ReplyDelete
  38. The proper bike storage will guarantee your bikes are safe, organized, and always in a convenient place. Here are some of the best options to get anyone started in the right direction. lightweight fiber road bicycle wheelset

    ReplyDelete
  39. Top Hindi Song download bangla song, bangla natok, hindi song, indian bangla song, bangla video, hindi video, bhoot fm, dor, radio program.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Check latest bikes, motorcycle prices in Bangladesh 2021 at bikesbd.net bike price in bd

    ReplyDelete
  41. Selamat siang untuk seluruh WNI dan juga seluruh ASIA, nama saya Bu Nurliana Novi, mohon, saya ingin membagikan testimoni hidup saya di sini pada platform ini untuk semua WNI dan seluruh asia agar berhati-hati dengan pemberi pinjaman di internet, Allah benar-benar telah mendukung saya melalui ibu. Ibu Elina yang baik hati
    Setelah beberapa periode mencoba mendapatkan pinjaman dari lembaga keuangan, dan ditolak terus-menerus, jadi saya memutuskan untuk mendaftar melalui pinjaman online tetapi saya ditipu dan saya kehilangan Rp 15.000.000 dengan pemberi pinjaman yang berbeda.

    Saking nekadnya mendapatkan pinjaman, maka saya berdiskusi dengan teman saya yang kemudian mengenalkan saya kepada Bu Elina yang merupakan pemilik perusahaan pemberi pinjaman global, maka teman saya tersebut meminta saya untuk melamar ke Bu Elina, maka saya pun memberanikan diri. dan menghubungi Nyonya Elina.

    Saya mengajukan pinjaman sejumlah Rp500.000.000 dengan tingkat bunga 2%, sehingga pinjaman disetujui dengan mudah tanpa stres dan semua pengaturan dilakukan pada transfer kredit, karena tidak memerlukan agunan dan jaminan untuk pinjaman transfer Saya hanya diberitahu untuk mendapatkan sertifikat perjanjian lisensi aplikasi Mereka untuk mentransfer kredit saya dan dalam waktu kurang dari dua jam uang pinjaman telah disimpan ke rekening bank saya.

    Saya pikir itu lelucon sampai saya menerima telepon dari bank saya bahwa rekening saya dikreditkan dengan jumlah Rp500.000.000. Saya sangat senang bahwa ALLAH akhirnya menjawab doa saya dengan memesan pinjaman saya dengan pinjaman asli saya, yang telah memberikan saya keinginan hati saya.

    Mereka juga memiliki tim ahli yang akan memberi tahu Anda tentang jenis bisnis yang ingin Anda investasikan dan bagaimana menginvestasikan uang Anda, sehingga Anda tidak akan pernah bangkrut lagi dalam hidup Anda.

    Semoga ALLAH memberkati Bunda Elina yang telah membuat hidup saya mudah, jadi saya menyarankan siapapun yang berminat untuk mendapatkan pinjaman agar dapat menghubungi Ibu Elina melalui email: elinajohnson22@gmail.com untuk pinjaman anda
    Ada perusahaan palsu online lainnya yang menggunakan kesaksian saya untuk mencapai keinginan egois mereka, saya satu-satunya dengan kesaksian yang benar ini, ketika Anda menghubungi kemudian meminta mereka untuk bukti pembayaran ke ibu`` tolong hati-hati orang-orang ini oke

    Akhir kata saya ucapkan terima kasih kepada kalian semua yang telah meluangkan waktu untuk membaca kesaksian hidup saya yang sebenarnya tentang kesuksesan saya dan saya berdoa semoga Tuhan melakukan kehendak-Nya dalam hidup kalian. Satu lagi nama saya mrs nurliana novi, kalian dapat menghubungi saya untuk informasi lebih lanjut. melalui email saya: nurliananovi96@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  42. The way our body needs care and regular checking, even the trucks need the same. There are many of the similarities between the truck mechanism and human body mechanism. Here we have offered tips for many of the points that should be considered by any of the truck owner in order to make the trucks functioning well and to give longer lasting utilities to the owner. car checker

    ReplyDelete
  43. If you are looking out for ways in which you might be able to find used tow trucks, you have come to the right place. With the information provided here, you should have no difficulty in tracking and identifying trucks that can serve the purpose in the long run. Many people out there are not completely aware of these trucks, which is probably the reason why they end up spending so much time trying to look everywhere with limited success. Tow truck Louisa va

    ReplyDelete
  44. What does FedEx, Pfizer, Wachovia, 3Com, Mellon Financial, Shurgard Storage, Sempra Energy and Proctor & Gamble have in common? Technology decisions will outlive the tenure of the management team making those decisions. Why do only 10% of public companies have IT Audit Committee? Beijing Soonercleaning Technology

    ReplyDelete
  45. A complete range of automotive tools and equipment can be found online. Consumers do have the advantage when shopping on the Internet, as they are not only provided quality merchandise, but merchandise at a discount. truck bedliner

    ReplyDelete
  46. As we expected, since publishing Crypto TREND we have received many questions from readers. In this edition we will answer the most common one. wazirx referral code

    ReplyDelete
  47. It is in no doubt that you will hear many people complain about the mistakes they make when they started their first website. The most common mistake amongst them all is the choice of a wrong domain name or web hosting plan. When it comes to hosting your website on the World Wide Web, you should look for a few things, namely reliability, trust and service. Cheap Web Hosting

    ReplyDelete
  48. I’m not that much of a internet reader to be honest but your blogs really nice, keep it up! I’ll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back in the future. Many thanks|

    Feel free to surf to my page - 안마


    ReplyDelete
  49. Can I just say what a reduction to find someone who truly is aware of what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know tips on how to convey a problem to light and make it important. More individuals have to read this and perceive this side of the story. I cant consider youre not more common because you positively have the gift. 가입시 꽁머니 사이트

    ReplyDelete
  50. I visited a lot of website but I believe this one has got something extra in it. 가입시 꽁머니 사이트

    ReplyDelete
  51. It professes to fuel the quickest, social media development so that you can guide offers via that. From specific crowd to absolutely loaded improvement bundles to top rate site visitors, Gainsfollower.Com offers the whole lot. Besides, you could music down your appropriate package and get it via a singular, custom designed dashboard that makes the route quite simple.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Leasing equipment is a quick and affordable solution for business owners who are looking to expand their business without major cash outlay. Nationwide, approximately 40 percent of equipment is leased and about 80 percent of businesses lease some of their equipment. Medical professionals often prefer leasing equipment, as the equipment can be expensive to buy, has a long life, and won't return a profit for years. caluanie usa price

    ReplyDelete
  53. Technology & HR-Leverage one for the other: "Technology and HR are enablers of business. Integration of the two would mean not only harmonious co-existence but also leveraging one for the other. Leveraging of technology for HR would mean digitizing the mundane HR activities and automating the back office and transactional activities related to recruitment, performance management, career planning, and succession planning, training and knowledge management. Leveraging HR for technology implies managing change associated with technology by way of communication, training, hiring, retraining, stakeholder analysis and conscious keeping. Thus they can play complementary roles." pegasus Spyware

    ReplyDelete
  54. Recruitment Technology has for a long time fallen behind the developments in other professional industries such as accounting, legal, insurance etc. with a number of excellent technology tools and software products being developed in these areas. Recently though their has been a surge of development within recruitment technology with some truly fantastic products being developed to take us out of the dark ages of recruitment methodologies. But if recruiters don't embrace this development we will hinder our progress into the future. Design Thinking

    ReplyDelete
  55. Good computer game writing is mostly found in two major genres of games. Role playing games and first person shooter games. However, it wasn't always the case! FPS games were once only considered great for their engine and available weapons. However the Half Life series and Deus Ex changed all of that. active discord servers

    ReplyDelete
  56. Despite the need for regular car maintenance and services like dent removal or body repair, consumers today often place the concerns of the environment above their own automotive needs. It makes sense; after all, our vehicles already put a strain on the ecological system, so it seems almost wasteful to put more chemicals into the earth for what seem to be cosmetic repairs. Fortunately, today's vehicle owners can have their cake and eat it too, with the help of paintless dent removal. car Welding Tools

    ReplyDelete
  57. Thank you for helping people get the information they need. Great stuff as usual. Keep up the great work!!! YouStable

    ReplyDelete
  58. When we see a Harley Davidson cruising on the roads, one can't help but admire the sleekness of the machine and the way it hugs and glides along. But what we at that time fail to realize is that the component that helps the bike to cruise along the road with such beauty is the motorcycle tire. used tires houston texas

    ReplyDelete
  59. Is your old technology replaced with new technology before you're ready to let it go? And does technology sometimes move too fast? Or is it really just moving too slow? Pressure washing houston tx

    ReplyDelete
  60. Recruitment Technology has for a long time fallen behind the developments in other professional industries such as accounting, legal, insurance etc. with a number of excellent technology tools and software products being developed in these areas. Recently though their has been a surge of development within recruitment technology with some truly fantastic products being developed to take us out of the dark ages of recruitment methodologies. But if recruiters don't embrace this development we will hinder our progress into the future. Individual income tax

    ReplyDelete
  61. When it comes to trying to find effective ways of doing home improvement, there is a wealth of knowledge at your fingertips should you choose to use the home improvement web. Now, many of you may be asking, 'what exactly is this home improvement websites and how can it assist me with the task of improving my home?' well the answer is actually quite simple. smash and grab prices pretoria

    ReplyDelete
  62. Numerous commercial and residential real estate development projects are stuck in a holding pattern as developers find it increasingly difficult to secure financing and investment participation. So how do you "un-stick" a real estate development project in today's economy? Many real estate development projects can benefit from various strategies that can be implemented to convert them into revenue-generating profit centers despite the current economic and financial barriers and challenges that exist today. This article provides 5 practical strategies and examples for "un-sticking" real estate development projects that are stuck in a holding pattern due to the lingering effects of the economic downturn of recent years. commercial property for sale
    In today's economy, one thing is guaranteed. The world is attempting to ditch the US dollar as the reserve currency and keeping your money in CDs and money market accounts is straight forward unsafe. For decades savers and investors found it safe to keep their money parked with their banks however the current near zero rates of interest and volatility of the U.S. dollar are justified reasons that compel more folks to find better investment strategies for their money. Read on to discover a passive way to invest in real estate, a technique your Wall Street broker would not dare to mention to you. commercial property for rent

    ReplyDelete
  63. Anonymous2:40 AM

    Your blog is a treasure trove of practical tips and advice. I've implemented many of your suggestions with great success. Buy best employee tracking software from best employee tracking software

    ReplyDelete
  64. Movies are not just stories on screen; they are windows into diverse universes of emotions and experiences. At TheFlixerz, we're passionate about curating an exceptional collection of films that cater to every cinematic taste. From heart-pounding action to heartwarming dramas, spine-tingling thrillers to side-splitting comedies, and thought-provoking documentaries to epic blockbusters, our carefully selected lineup has something for everyone

    ReplyDelete
  65. Our myths In a small town, Varun and Rajkummar work as lady-of-the-hour merchants and part-time crooks. They receive a commission to kidnap Janvhi, a young woman; however, there is a fight before the wedding, and they are instructed to take her to a lodge and detain her until they receive more demands from the prospective husband's side. Visit here:hdmovieslounge

    ReplyDelete
  66. Within the cutthroat world of internet streaming, YesMovies has established a solid place for itself. YesMovies serves its user base's varied preferences with a wide library of films covering a variety of genres, from timeless classics to the newest blockbusters.The platform's broad appeal can be attributed to its dedication to offering a flawless streaming experience devoid of subscription requirements. Visit here:thenewssprout

    ReplyDelete
  67. Anonymous6:28 AM

    The last chords of the investigation into thesparkshop.in:product/batman-style-wireless-bt-earbuds resound with a symphony of inventiveness and aural expertise. When customers purchase earbuds from the digital symposium of sound and combine it with the classic Caped Crusader style, they are entering a world where function and fandom collide.

    ReplyDelete
  68. Anonymous6:46 AM

    When we work our way through the complex terrain of the term iversær the finish is the climax, the pinnacle of understanding. "Iversær" is more than simply a word; it represents a spirit of originality, a departure from the norm, and a change that characterises what makes anything truly unique.

    ReplyDelete
  69. Use our Free SMM Panel to start a free journey to increase your social media presence. Our platform is committed to offering social media services that are accessible to everyone without requiring payment.

    ReplyDelete